Tub to Shower Conversion in Shelter Island, NY
Transform Your Bathroom in Just Days
Get the modern, accessible shower you need without the hassle of a full renovation.
Hear from Our Customers
Shower Conversion Solutions Shelter Island
Step Into Safety and Style
Your old tub isn’t just taking up space—it’s creating safety risks every time you climb over that high wall. A tub to shower conversion eliminates the barriers that make bathing dangerous, especially as we age.
You’ll wake up to a bathroom that feels bigger, looks modern, and actually works for your daily routine. No more unused tub collecting dust. No more worrying about slips and falls.
The space opens up. Your morning routine speeds up. And your home value goes up. That’s what happens when you replace an outdated bathtub with a sleek, functional shower designed for real life.
Bathtub Replacement Experts Shelter Island
Two Decades of Glass Expertise
We’ve been serving Long Island families for over 20 years from our Copiague location. We’re not just another contractor—we’re glass specialists who understand exactly what it takes to transform your bathroom safely and beautifully.
Shelter Island homeowners trust us because we show up when we say we will, do the work right the first time, and clean up completely when we’re done. Our family-owned business has completed thousands of shower conversions across Suffolk and Nassau counties.
We know the unique challenges of working in Shelter Island’s older homes, many built in the 1970s. Ferry schedules, island logistics, and historic home considerations—we’ve handled it all.
Bathroom Conversion Process Shelter Island
Simple Steps to Your New Shower
First, we measure your existing space and discuss your vision. Every bathroom is different, and we need to understand your specific needs—whether that’s grab bars for safety, built-in seating, or just maximizing the space you have.
Next, we handle the removal of your old tub and any necessary plumbing adjustments. Our team protects your home during this process, containing dust and debris so the rest of your house stays clean.
Then comes the installation of your new shower base, walls, and glass enclosure. We use high-quality materials designed to last decades, not years. The final step is our detailed cleanup and walkthrough to ensure everything meets our standards and yours.
Ready to get started?
Custom Glass Shower Installation Shelter Island
Built for Shelter Island Living
Your conversion includes everything needed for a complete transformation: professional-grade shower base, waterproof wall systems, and custom glass enclosures that fit your space perfectly. We don’t use one-size-fits-all solutions.
Shelter Island’s unique location means we plan every detail in advance. Materials arrive on schedule, work progresses efficiently, and we coordinate around ferry times to minimize any inconvenience to your daily routine.
Many of our Shelter Island clients choose accessibility features like low-threshold entries, grab bars, and built-in seating. These aren’t just safety additions—they’re smart investments that make your bathroom work better for everyone, regardless of age or mobility.
How much does a tub to shower conversion cost in Shelter Island?
Most tub to shower conversions in Shelter Island range from $3,000 to $8,000, depending on the size of your space, materials chosen, and any custom features you want. The wide range reflects the difference between basic conversions and premium installations with custom glass and accessibility features.
Several factors affect your final cost: the condition of your existing plumbing, whether you want to relocate the shower, and what type of materials you select. We provide detailed estimates that break down every component so you know exactly what you’re paying for.
Keep in mind that Shelter Island’s location may affect material delivery costs, but we factor this into our quotes upfront. No surprises, no hidden fees—just honest pricing for quality work.
How long does a bathtub to shower conversion take to complete?
Most conversions take 3-5 days from start to finish, though this can vary based on the complexity of your project. Simple conversions where we’re working in the same footprint move faster than projects requiring plumbing relocation or structural modifications.
Day one typically involves removal of the old tub and any necessary prep work. Days two and three cover installation of the new shower base, walls, and plumbing connections. The final days involve installing your glass enclosure and completing all finishing touches.
We coordinate our schedule around Shelter Island’s ferry times and always communicate our daily progress. You’ll know exactly when we’ll arrive and what we’ll accomplish each day, so you can plan accordingly.
Can you make my new shower accessible for aging in place?
Absolutely. Many of our Shelter Island clients specifically request accessibility features, and we’re experienced in creating showers that work beautifully for aging in place. Low-threshold or curbless entries eliminate the step-over barrier that makes traditional tubs dangerous.
We can install grab bars in optimal locations, add built-in seating, and ensure your controls are positioned for easy reach. These features integrate seamlessly into the design—they enhance both safety and aesthetics rather than looking like medical equipment.
The key is planning these features from the beginning rather than trying to add them later. We’ll discuss your current and future needs during our consultation to create a shower that serves you well for decades to come.
Do I need permits for a tub to shower conversion in Shelter Island?
Yes, most tub to shower conversions require permits in Shelter Island, especially when plumbing modifications are involved. We handle the permit application process as part of our service, ensuring all work meets local building codes and inspection requirements.
The permit process typically takes 1-2 weeks, which we factor into your project timeline. We submit detailed plans showing the proposed changes and coordinate with local inspectors to schedule required inspections during construction.
Working with permits protects you by ensuring the work is done to code and properly documented. This is especially important for insurance purposes and if you ever decide to sell your home. Buyers want to see that major bathroom renovations were done legally and professionally.
Will converting my tub to a shower affect my home's resale value?
A well-executed tub to shower conversion typically increases your home’s value, especially in Shelter Island’s market where many buyers prefer modern, accessible bathrooms. Studies show conversions can provide up to 74% return on investment when done with quality materials and professional installation.
The key is ensuring you still have at least one bathtub elsewhere in your home. Families with children often want a tub somewhere in the house, so completely eliminating all tubs can limit your buyer pool.
In Shelter Island’s aging demographic, accessibility features actually add significant value. Buyers increasingly prioritize safety and universal design, making an accessible shower a strong selling point rather than a limitation.
What makes OMG Shower Doors different from other bathroom contractors?
We specialize exclusively in glass and shower solutions, which means we’re not generalists trying to do everything. Our 20+ years of experience focuses specifically on what we do best: creating beautiful, functional shower spaces with custom glass enclosures.
Our island experience matters. We understand Shelter Island’s logistics, from ferry scheduling to working in historic homes. We’ve solved the unique challenges that come with island living and older home renovations countless times before.
Most importantly, we show up when promised and deliver what we quote. Our reputation in the Long Island community is built on reliability, quality work, and treating every home with respect. We’re not the cheapest option, but we’re the one you can count on to do the job right the first time.
Local Resources
Useful Links
Other Services we provide in Shelter Island
