Tub to Shower Conversion in Shelter Island Heights
Safe, Accessible Showers That Actually Fit Your Life
Stop climbing over that tub rim every morning—get a walk-in shower that makes bathing simple, safe, and stylish again.
Hear from Our Customers
Bathtub Replacement Shelter Island Heights NY
What Your Bathroom Looks Like After
No more worrying about slipping while stepping over a high tub wall. Your new walk-in shower gives you easy, safe access every single day.
You’ll have more space, better water pressure, and a bathroom that actually works for your needs. Plus, modern walk-in showers are easier to clean and maintain than old bathtubs that collect soap scum and grime.
The best part? Your shower becomes the focal point of a refreshed bathroom that feels bigger, brighter, and more functional than before.
Shower Door Installation Shelter Island Heights
Three Decades of Getting It Right
We’ve been transforming Long Island bathrooms for over 30 years. We’re a family-owned company that understands what Shelter Island Heights residents need—quality work, fair pricing, and respect for your home.
We know this area. We understand that many of our neighbors are looking for safer, more accessible bathroom solutions as they age in place. That’s why we specialize in creating beautiful walk-in showers that solve real problems.
Our team brings decades of glass expertise to every project, and we’re known for having the fastest turnaround time in the industry—most customers go from first call to finished shower in just two weeks.
Bathtub to Shower Conversion Process
Simple Process, Professional Results
First, we come to your home for a free consultation and precise measurements. We’ll discuss your needs, show you options, and provide a clear quote with no surprises.
Next, we handle the removal of your old bathtub and prepare the space for your new shower. This includes any necessary plumbing adjustments, waterproofing, and structural modifications.
Finally, we install your new shower base, walls, and custom glass door. We clean up completely and walk you through everything so you know exactly how to care for your new shower. Most projects are completed in one to two weeks from start to finish.
Ready to get started?
Walk-in Shower Benefits Shelter Island Heights
Why Shelter Island Heights Residents Choose Shower Conversions
In a community where 60% of residents are over 64, safety isn’t just a nice-to-have—it’s essential. Walk-in showers eliminate the dangerous step-over that causes thousands of bathroom falls each year.
Shelter Island Heights homes often feature smaller bathrooms where space matters. Converting your unused tub creates up to 30% more usable floor space, making your bathroom feel significantly larger.
With the area’s high property values—median home value over $1 million—a quality tub to shower conversion typically returns 60-74% of your investment. You’re not just improving your daily life; you’re making a smart financial decision.
How much does a tub to shower conversion cost in Shelter Island Heights?
Most tub to shower conversions in Shelter Island Heights range from $3,000 to $8,000, depending on the materials you choose and the complexity of your project. Basic conversions with standard materials start around $3,000, while custom tile work with premium fixtures can reach $8,000 or more.
The final cost depends on factors like your current plumbing setup, the size of your new shower, and whether you want features like built-in seating or grab bars. We provide detailed, upfront quotes so you know exactly what to expect before we start.
How long does a bathtub to shower conversion take to complete?
Most tub to shower conversions take one to two weeks from start to finish. The actual construction work typically takes 3-5 days, but the timeline includes ordering your custom materials and scheduling around your convenience.
At OMG Shower Doors, we’re known for having the fastest turnaround time in the industry. Many of our Shelter Island Heights customers go from initial consultation to finished shower in just two weeks. We coordinate everything so you’re never left without a working bathroom for more than necessary.
Will converting my tub to a shower affect my home's resale value?
A quality tub to shower conversion typically returns 60-74% of your investment, especially in high-value areas like Shelter Island Heights. However, this assumes you have at least one other bathtub elsewhere in your home.
The key is doing it right with quality materials and professional installation. Buyers today—particularly in communities with aging populations—often prefer accessible walk-in showers over traditional tubs. A well-designed conversion can actually make your home more appealing to potential buyers.
Can you make my new shower safer for aging in place?
Absolutely. We specialize in creating showers that work for people of all ages and mobility levels. This includes zero-threshold entries that eliminate tripping hazards, built-in seating for comfort, and strategically placed grab bars that blend seamlessly with your design.
We can also install non-slip flooring, handheld shower heads that adjust to any height, and adequate lighting for safety. Many of our Shelter Island Heights customers specifically request these features to help them age safely in their own homes.
Do I need permits for a tub to shower conversion?
In most cases, yes—tub to shower conversions typically require permits, especially when plumbing modifications are involved. The good news is that we handle the permit process for you as part of our service.
We’re familiar with local building codes and requirements in Shelter Island Heights and Suffolk County. We’ll pull the necessary permits, schedule required inspections, and ensure everything meets current safety standards. This protects you and ensures your conversion is done legally and safely.
What happens if I change my mind and want my bathtub back?
While most people love their new walk-in showers, we understand that circumstances can change. The good news is that shower-to-tub conversions are possible, though they typically cost more than the original conversion.
If you’re concerned about this, we recommend keeping your original tub components during the initial conversion (we can store them for you). This makes any future reversal much more cost-effective. However, in our 30+ years of experience, fewer than 2% of customers ever request to go back to a bathtub.
Local Resources
Useful Links
Other Services we provide in Shelter Island Heights
